A Space for Everyone

Clockwise from upper left: Melanie Bernhardt, Bob Follet, Diane Follet, Jane Hannauer

At a recent chamber music weekend, a friend and I had two completely different reactions to playing with an individual who clearly was having physical difficulties. These differences led to the exploration of the following questions: When should one put down one’s instrument? Should friends discourage friends from playing when their physical capabilities are compromised?

The weekend in question was a semi-annual meetup of roughly 60 string players and a few pianists. There are 3 sessions a day, 2 hours each, over the course of a long weekend. There are no entrance criteria. All are welcome to participate. Participants are placed in a different group each session and the group reads whatever music they choose. For those who want to prepare something in advance, there are suggestions provided. There is no coaching;
the only costs are lodging, travel and a very small administrative fee (under $100!). As would be expected in this context, the skill level varies dramatically, from people who are relatively new, inexperienced players to those at expert level who also attend top tier, highly selective workshops. Until the most recent weekend, however, I didn’t realize how wide the skill level might be.

In workshops such as these, where anybody can show up, I expect that I will get at least one bad session. In my definition, a “bad session” is one in which one or more players can’t follow the music or they play completely out of tune or they carry a tempo that doesn’t match anybody else’s or they can’t count, or, or, or….you get the picture. This happens at least once in these settings and is to be expected. In the most recent workshop, however, I was placed in
a string quartet with a violist, I’ll call him Mark, who had what I assume was a very pronounced essential tremor.

When I played with Mark I was completely distracted by the uncontrolled movements of his bow arm. He clearly had some physical issue and although he was playing, very little sound was coming out. When I did hear notes, they were always a bit behind where they should have been. I assume this also was due to a lack of motor control. I could hear enough to imagine that Mark had been at least a decent player at some point, but simply could not make it happen anymore.

With his spastic movements and barely audible notes always behind the rest of us, sitting next to Mark was hard. I had a difficult time focusing and staying with the other 2 players, trying to make music while distracted by the jerky actions happening to my left. I started to get irritated. I started to wonder who had let Mark be a part of the weekend. Who had let this guy in? Of course the answer was that the nature of this particular weekend is that everybody is allowed in. So then I wondered, why does Mark want to be here? Surely he knows that he can’t
control his bow. Surely he knows that his playing is not good — that he’s not making a nice sound or keeping up with the rest of us. So why is he here? Why is he exposing himself in this way?

There was only one answer that came to mind. He was enjoying it! He was having fun! He was appreciating what he was able to do rather than focusing on what he was unable to do. And along the way he was enjoying the camaraderie and personal connection that comes with playing chamber music. This realization allowed me to shift my own focus. My job during this session wasn’t to make beautiful music for all to hear. My job was to create a space where Mark could have the pleasure of playing. His distracting movements were still a challenge, but now, rather than being resentful about them I could have compassion and keep my eyes on my own music, allowing Mark to do his thing to the best of his ability. It was frustrating and difficult playing with Mark, but everybody in the group was kind. We prevailed and had a 2-hour session of string quartets that had some decent musical moments. I was exhausted from the efforts and reported as much to my housemates afterwards.

The next day one of my housemates – I’ll call her Connie – was assigned a session with Mark. Connie is an avid and accomplished chamber violinist. She is also one of the most prepared and conscientious people I know. After her session with Mark she begged us to promise that if she ever got to such a state as Mark’s that we would insist she put down her fiddle. She was absolutely adamant that she did NOT want to make others suffer by having to play with somebody so compromised; we absolutely were not to allow her to ever do so. The contrast between our reactions disturbed me greatly, and it took several days for me to figure out why. Why had the two of us had such different reactions to playing with the same perfectly nice but physically challenged person? Connie is not an unkind person, but she does expect a lot of herself and, my extension, of others. Her request, in fact, was to prevent the suffering of others. I listened, but was silently unwilling to make that promise. Why? And why did the request stick with me for days? As I thought about this, flashbacks to conversations with other musicians came to mind.

There was the conversation with Phyllis at a continuing care retirement community who had just gotten back from playing duets with Stacy, who was in the nursing home section. Stacy couldn’t really play anymore, but she absolutely loved whenever Phyllis showed up with her violin and offered to play duets. I got the impression that not much music came out during those sessions, but Phyllis went with her violin once a week and “played duets” with Stacy, much to Stacy’s delight.

I also thought about the story of Daniel, who had been a very accomplished cellist and was now living in an Alzheimer’s ward. His daughters, one a violinist, the other a violist, visit often, bringing their instruments. When they ask Daniel if he wants to play he will happily toddle over to an armless chair, plop down with legs spread, and one of the daughters will place his cello “in position”. Sometimes Daniel doesn’t make it past playing scales; sometimes some form of duet gets played. But whatever actual music comes out doesn’t matter. Daniel’s eyes light up at the suggestion of playing the cello. No matter the sound produced, it still brings him great joy. From these stories and my experience with Mark I now understand that, at least for me, the music we hear with our hearts is always more important than the music we hear with our ears. This may not be true for everyone and it certainly isn’t true in all situations. We attend performances by world class ensembles expecting amazing music to enter our ears. And for some, the pursuit of audible perfection may be most important. But through this experience I came to understand that for me, the music we hear with our hearts is always more important than that which we hear with our ears. This was a profound realization and it explains a lot of my willingness to let go of perfection when playing in groups. What I had previously labeled in myself as laziness, or not caring enough to make the most perfect music possible, I now understand in a completely different light.

We often hear about including younger people and offering exposure for them to play with more experienced players. But what about players on the other side of that mountain – those whose capabilities are declining, not ascending? While there absolutely is a need for workshops that are selective, where the capabilities of players are well matched and where the goal is to create the best possible music, we also benefit when we provide space for those who don’t play as well as they once did.

To the questions of when one should put down their instrument or whether friends should tell friends that they should no longer play, I would say that we should keep playing as long as we enjoy it. As friends, we may want to direct people with compromised capabilities toward inclusive workshops and away from those that are more competitive. We may want to find places where kindness matters more than the quality of the sound being produced and discourage application to a Manhattan String Quartet Intensive, for example. I now understand
that just the act of playing can be what is most important.

What comes out in audible form doesn’t always matter. The social interaction and the remembering of what one has enjoyed throughout life can sometimes matter more. The playing of an instrument, no matter how poorly,
allows one’s soul to sing. And it’s important to have a space for this to happen.I am grateful to have had my experience with Mark. I am grateful that there is a place where he feels comfortable and where he can be accepted. I am grateful that my friend Connie was open about her concerns. Because now, Connie, I promise you this: Should your physical capabilities ever decline to the point where it might be miserable for others to play with you, as long as you wish to play, as long as it would be fun for you, as long as it would give you pleasure, it will be my honor to make music with you. I will close my ears, open my heart, and we will make beautiful music – no matter how it sounds. All names have been changed to protect the privacy of the participants.

More Articles

Giving Tuesday is December 3rd!

This Giving Tuesday, please play your part in supporting ACMP's international community of passionate amateur chamber players and the world’s only grants program for adult amateur chamber music!

Read More ↗

Q&A: Taking up the cello in later life

The senior years in life are often associated retiring, slowing down or playing golf. But Mavis Himes had a different idea: She took up the cello. It was a long-held dream, one that she needed to act on. Six years later, she is still going strong, despite setbacks like a bicycle accident and an arduous recovery.

Read More ↗

Support ACMP through holiday shopping!

It's almost the holiday season and you can support ACMP by holiday shopping at our store! We have 2 new original cartoon mugs, holiday cards, cute cocktail napkins and a book by Lucy Miller-Murray.

Read More ↗

Music for Two Violins: Personal Reflections on a Forgotten Genre

For the past seven years ACMP coach Gabriel Schaff has had the pleasure of discovering a corner of the chamber music repertoire that he now considers to be undervalued and under-explored: music for two violins. Read about the gems of this repertoire, from the Baroque era through the twentieth century.

Read More ↗

Sixty years after its founding, the Houston Civic Symphony is going strong

Houston, Texas has a long-standing arts tradition, including the region's oldest community orchestra, The Houston Civic Symphony. The group was founded in 1964, and sixty years later it's still going strong!

Read More ↗

Winter in Vermont: Decoda launches its first-ever adult amateur retreat

The Affiliate Ensemble of Carnegie Hall, Decoda, is launching its first-ever adult amateur chamber music retreat at the historic Marlboro Music Festival campus, Potash Hill in January 2025. Read Stephanie Griffin's interview with Decoda clarinetist and workshop organizer Alicia Lee.

Read More ↗

ACMP Listening Club: Demystifying Charles Ives with violinist Gregory Fulkerson on Sunday, December 8 at 2pm ET

Join violinist and Ives scholar Gregory Fulkerson on Sunday, December 8 at 2pm Eastern for an in-depth discussion of Charles Ives' life, background and music, with a special focus on his String Quartet no. 1 (1896- 1902), in celebration of the groundbreaking composer's 150th birthday!

Read More ↗

ACMP Listening Club: Brahms Piano Quintet in f minor, Op. 34

Get ready to dive into Brahm's Piano Quintet in f minor, Op. 34 with Peter Fender on Sunday, November 10 at 2pm on Zoom. Learn more about the background of this masterwork and get pro tips on interpretation and performance practice.

Read More ↗

Join ACMP at the CMA National Conference in Houston, February 13-16, 2025

Join ACMP for an action-packed chamber music vacation in Houston, Texas this February at the CMA National Conference. We're making history! For the first time in ACMP's long-standing relationship with CMA we are collaborating with them on their annual conference as a Partner Organization. We've made sure there are many fabulous activities of interest to all of you who play chamber music for pleasure.

Read More ↗

ACMP Film Club: “Through the Darkness”

Celebrating Schoenberg at 150: Watch Hilan Warshaw's documentary film and meet him at ACMP Film Club on Sunday, October 6 at 2pm ET on Zoom.

Read More ↗

The Daraja Music Initiative: 15 years of Music and Conservation in Tanzania

Since 2017, ACMP member clarinetist and nonprofit leader Alexys Bush has traveled to Tanzania, Africa where she teaches general music and clarinet for the Daraja Music Initiative (DMI), for whom she serves as Assistant Director. DMI bridges music education and the conservation of Tanzania's national tree - the African Blackwood, also known as ebony - used to make clarinets, oboes, piccolos, and some string fingerboards. It's not too late to get involved in DMI's 15th anniversary season as a volunteer!

Read More ↗

Playing for Good: The Mystic String Quartet and Big Lux

The Mystic Quartet joins forces with hip-hop violinist Big Lux in a unique and highly creative concert program, "Harmony Not Hate," on as a benefit for the Southern Poverty Law Center at 4pm on October 19 at Saint Mark's Episcopal Church in Mystic, Connecticut. Read about the thinking behind the program, their discovery of new works through the Kronos Quartet "Fifty for the Future" online library, and their adventures working with a renowned hip-hop artist - and support their cause!

Read More ↗

How to convert a Merton Music 2-up Booklet to a Single-Page PDF

Struggling to convert those pesky booklet-style Merton Music pdfs in IMSLP to a single-page pdf that you can easily print or read on your iPad? ACMP member Tom Frenkel has figured it out! Read his handy guide.

Read More ↗

Win 2 tickets to Peoples’ Symphony Chamber Concerts!

Read More ↗

ECUADOR, MEXICO AND SPAIN: WINE & FRIENDSHIP

Music can bridge cultural divides and connect people from all over the world. Read Catalina Paredes' story about the "Just Play" concert in Quito on July 27, 2024.

Read More ↗

New Listening Club Video: Peter Fender on Schubert’s Octet

Out now! Watch the video recording from our recent Listening Club event with British conductor, composer, and educator Peter Fender on Franz Schubert’s delightful Octet in F major, D. 803.

Read More ↗

CAMMAC receives the 2024 Susan McIntosh Lloyd Award

On Tuesday, July 16, 2024, Corinne Bergeron presented ACMP's annual Susan McIntosh Lloyd Award to CAMMAC (Canadian Amateur Musicians - Musiciens Amateurs du Canada) in Harrington, Québec. CAMMAC is the first international recipient of this award since it was launched in 2016.

Read More ↗

ACMP supports the Afghan National Institute of Music

ACMP gave a grant to the Afghan National Institute of Music (ANIM) in Braga, Portugal, in support of its unique and varied chamber music program. Read ACMP's interview with ANIM's founder and director, Dr. Ahmad Sarmast

Read More ↗

Play-In Season in British Columbia, Part II: Vancouver

Vancouver NAOC councilor Christina Wolf hosted the official ACMP Vancouver Worldwide Play-In event on May 20, 2024 at Arts Umbrella on Granville Island. Twenty string players and two pianists were in attendance, from Vancouver and its outlying suburbs, Vancouver Island, Bellingham, Washington and The Bronx, NY.

Read More ↗

Play-In Season in British Columbia, Part I: Nanaimo

This Play-In season, Stephanie and her partner Hilliard Greene attended ACMP Play-Ins in British Columbia, Canada, starting with a visit with Jane Stein Wilson in Nanaimo.

Read More ↗

Load More

 

All Articles By