Amateurs and Contemporary Music: The Prevailing Winds

Composer György Kurtág

A case for amateurs and their mentors to include contemporary music in their regular repertoire.

In my last article for the ACMP Newsletter, “The Haydn Neglect,” I pled a case for amateurs to perform more Haydn and to perceive his music in an imaginative way.  On quite a different tack, I now plead with amateurs and their mentors to consider contemporary music as part of their regular repertoire.Even though I pled a case for amateurs to perform more Haydn and to perceive his music in an imaginative way in an article for the ACMP Newsletter, “The Haydn Neglect,” (issue TK) I say this as I am struggling joyfully with Beethoven’s Op. 16 Piano Quartet, but modern music never moves far from my music rack be it music of the 20th or 21st century and even some recently composed work that I have been lucky enough to encounter.

How to make new music more accessible to amateurs remains a question separate from their playing contemporary music. I do not believe the answer lies in asking composers to write music technically easier for amateurs, but rather in begging amateurs to take on the challenges of playing new music much in the way they approach the difficulties of Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven. I believe there will be some surprises in store for those willing amateurs. The prospect of amateurs commissioning new works would of course be an added benefit to the currently rich world of composition.

In my recent book, Chamber Music: An Extensive Guide for Listeners (Rowman & Littlefield 2015), I have included thirty living composers among the some three hundred covered in the Classical, Romantic, and Modern periods. Also prevalent in the book are many works by 20th and 21st century composers whose music might prove of interest to amateur players looking for contemporary repertoire. While I often refer to virtuosic challenges in the modern works, I do not mean to imply that they are more difficult than those offered by Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven.

My own love of contemporary music can be traced back to my teenage years when my adventuresome piano teacher assigned William Schuman’s Three-Score Set, three brief piano works composed in 1943, for my recital before a high school audience. In the 1950s few high school students had even heard of William Schuman, then president of Juilliard and a highly honored composer. Years later, my admiration of contemporary music—and especially chamber music—continued as founding director of Market Square Concerts where many of the programs we presented included a new piece of music, sometimes even a world premiere of a work we commissioned.

Another fond memory of contemporary music is the Juilliard Quartet playing a fine new work by Richard Wernick which had come a long way from the Quartet’s performance which I had heard some months earlier in its New York premiere on January 22, 1990. Yes, even the Juilliard needed that time to become comfortable with a new piece, reminding us, indeed, that comfort is what we amateurs need in our approach to new music. Unlike traditional repertoire, little of new music is “in our ears” at first playing. This is not to say, however, that it will never enter the arena of familiarity once we have thoroughly worked with it. We may even find ourselves experiencing a remarkable discovery that Haydn is not so far from Schoenberg as we may have thought.

As an amateur pianist, a remarkable advancement in my understanding of new music came years ago when Richard Weinert (now President of Concert Artists Guild) and I undertook a performance of selections from György Kurtág’s Játékok (Games) IV for piano four hands at the Raphael Trio Chamber Music Workshop.  While other amateurs were whisking their way along the difficult but familiar paths of Mozart and Beethoven, Richard and I fought our way through Kurtág’s challenging work. The challenges, however, were as much in the reading as in the playing. We had to figure out Kurtág’s complex directions for bringing down our fists over a collection of notes and, in the final statement of “Köd-kánon” (Fog-canon), to extend both our arms and hands so that every note on the keyboard was played at once. At first we joked, but then, as we played on, the piece became more and more essentially musical and moving.  In a workshop performance, we brought down the house. I was reminded of something that John Cage once said about playing new music: “If something is boring after two minutes, try it for four. If still boring, then eight. Then sixteen. Then thirty-two. Eventually one discovers that it is not boring at all.”  So it was with Kurtág’s challenging Játékok. The works had originally been suggested to us by pianist Ursula Oppens, a champion of new music.

Another experience as an amateur exploring new music came when I asked James Bonn, then pianist of the Los Angeles Piano Quartet, to suggest a contemporary chamber music piece that might be attractive to amateur players.  Without hesitation, Jim presented me with November 19, 1838, a challenging but ultimately playable new work by John Harbison commissioned in 1988 by the National Endowment for the Arts Consortium and composed for the Atlanta Chamber Players, the Da Capo Chamber Players, and Voices of Change. I approached the piano part hesitantly because of its singular qualities but soon found myself engrossed in Harbison’s music. As the title implies, the work refers to the date of Schubert’s death and his miraculous life in music. The various sections were interestingly entitled:

I. Introduction: Schubert crosses into the next world
II. Suite: Schubert finds himself in a hall of mirrors

1. Theme
2. Écossaise
3. Moment Musicale
4. Impromptu
5. Valse

                        III. Rondo: Schubert recalls a rondo fragment from 1816
                        IV. Fugue: Schubert continues the fugue subject (S-C-H-U-B-E-R-T) that Sechter assigned him

*  *  *

Now let’s address the current state of affairs concerning amateurs and new music. For this I am turning again to some distinguished experts in the field whose workshops for amateurs I have attended. Daniel Epstein and Susan Salm are founders and directors the Raphael Trio Chamber Music Workshop held each August in High Mowing, New Hampshire. Speaking to them confirmed my hope that modern music has a strong presence in the repertoire of amateur players.  Yes, their participants play Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven, but they have also undertaken such 20th century composers as Arnold Schoenberg, Béla Bartók, Dmitri Shostakovich, Igor Stravinsky and later voices, namely, Benjamin Britten, Ned Rorem, Norman Dello Joio, and Quincy Porter.

Susan and Dan freely admit they do not force contemporary music on their participants but also insist that they welcome it. They note that the choice of new music often comes from some specific associations such as hearing it in performance or encountering it in some personal way.  A list of recent contemporary works performed by participants in the Raphael Trio Chamber Music Workshop at High Mowing includes:

                  Béla Bartók (1881-1945), Contrasts for Violin, Clarinet, and Piano, Sz. 111         

                  Benjamin Britten (1913-1976), Phantasy Quintet for Oboe and Strings, Op. 2

                  Norman Dello Joio (1913-2008), Trio for Flute, Cello, and Piano

                  Jean Francaix (1912-1997), Quintet for Clarinet and String Quartet;

                                    Trio for Flute, Cello, and Piano

                  Philippe Gaubert (1879-1941), Trois Aquarelles for Flute, Cello, and Piano

                  Charles Ives (1874-1954), String Quartet No. 1

                  Gordon Jacobs (1894-1985), Quintet for Clarinet and String Quintet

                  Charles Koechlin (1867-1950), Divertimento for Three Flutes, Op. 91

                  Bohuslav Martinů (1890-1959)

                                    Sonata for Flute, Violin, and Piano, H. 254

                                    Promenades for Flute, Violin, and Harpsichord, H. 274

                                    Madrigal-Sonata for Flute, Violin, and Piano, H. 291

                                    Trio for Flute, Violin, and Bassoon, H. 265

                                    Four Madrigals, for Oboe, Clarinet, and Bassoon, H. 266

                                    Trio for Flute, Cello, and Piano, H. 300

                  Andrea Molino (b. 1964), Trio for Flute, Viola, and Guitar

                  Quincy Porter (1897-1966), String Quartet No. 3               

                  Ned Rorem (b.1923), Trio for Flute, Cello, and Piano

                  Dmitri Dmitri Shostakovich (1906-1975), Piano Trio in E Minor, Op. 67

                  Igor Stravinsky (1882-1971), L’ Histoire du soldat for Violin, Clarinet, and Piano

While this telling list contains few works by living composers, it does reveal much music of the first half of the 20th century when Modernism was in full flourish. It also suggests that contemporary music for amateur performance is more readily sought by wind players. The obvious reason for this is the lack of chamber music repertoire for winds in comparison to that for string quartets, string trios, piano trios, piano quartets, and piano quintets. Interestingly, new music is currently helping to diminish that difference. The Raphael Trio list also reflects a specific flutist, Stephanie Bazirjian, a long-time participant in the Raphael Trio workshop and champion of contemporary music.  Cheers for her!

The distinguished professional flutist Mimi Stillman also encourages contemporary music at the Curtis Institute’s Summerfest program for amateurs where she serves on the faculty.  She confirms my thoughts on amateurs and contemporary music and its appeal for wind players in her comments. String players and pianists, she notes, have a full repertoire from the Baroque, Classical, and Romantic periods and even a wealth of well-known 20th century music available to them, but wind players, says Mimi, “by necessity play lesser-known composers and many 20th-century works that are staples in our repertoire. Eugene Bozza and Pierre Max Dubois are just two examples of 20th-century composers encountered by woodwind players more often than by their string and piano-playing peers. As for new music by living composers, many amateur flutists who play in flute ensembles—from duets to full flute choirs—are regularly exposed to music for these groups written for all levels of proficiency. Amateur flutists tend to be quite open-minded about new music.”  String players and pianists, let’s join them!

In conclusion I might say that I am not asking amateurs to abandon their dedication to traditional repertoire. I am simply asking them to open their minds and hearts to contemporary music if they have not already done so. The results may bring some wonderful surprises.

More Articles

GO FOR BAROQUE……an early music workshop in NYC

Read More ↗

How to hold a Play-In: January 28, 2023, 2pm ET on Zoom

Read More ↗

Announcing the 2022 Holiday Caption Contest Winners!

The winners of ACMP's 2022 Holiday Caption Contest are Hsing-ay Hsu, Victoria Bryan and Christopher Minarich. Check out their fun captions and read about our winners!

Read More ↗

 Chamber Music for Novice level players by Jill Schultz

Violinist and educator Jill Schultz shares tips on how to find satisfying chamber music repertoire for novice-level players.

Read More ↗

Just Play Concert: ACMP Members in California perform Beethoven and Gabriela Lena Frank

California ACMP members Sue Soong, Kevin Jim, Angus Davol and Julie Park perform an ambitious program of Beethoven and Gabriela Lena Frank at their concert in Albany, California, supported in part by ACMP.

Read More ↗

Watch the Kronos Quartet Master Class on YouTube

ACMP's first online master class with the Kronos Quartet on Saturday, November 12, 2022 was a success! Congratulations to the three groups from Idaho State University, the San Francisco Conservatory of Music and SUNY New Paltz who performed so beautifully. Watch the November class and sign up now to play on April 15.

Read More ↗

Featured ACMP Member Michael Knoch

Meet flutist Michael Knoch, ACMP's IAC Ambassador in Berlin, Germa

Read More ↗

Kronos Quartet Master Class Repertoire Reveal:

Three string quartets from Pocatello, Idaho; San Francisco, California; and New Paltz, New York will play works by Missy Mazzoli, Ken Benshoof and Charlton Singleton for members of the Kronos Quartet on Saturday, November 12 at 2pm Eastern on Zoom and YouTube.

Read More ↗

Featured ACMP Member: Virginia Feldman

Celeste Chau interviews Virginia Feldman, ACMP's Portland, Oregon representative on its North American Outreach Council.

Read More ↗

A Wonderful Day of Chamber Music at MCW!

Read More ↗

Tickets now available for the Kronos Quartet Masterclass on November 12

Reserve your free ticket now to watch the Kronos Quartet 50 for the Future Online Masterclass on Saturday, November 12 at 2pm Eastern on Zoom.

Read More ↗

“Fall Worldwide Play-In” grant cycle now open!

Read More ↗

Location search: By proximity? Or in a specific location?

An easy guide to searching the ACMP directories by location.

Read More ↗

A Tribute to Candice Chin (1976 – 2022)

Read More ↗

ACMP member adventures in Ecuador

ACMP members Tom Cappaert and Art Malm returned to Ecuador to pick up a newly commissioned viola, coach with Alejandro Jiménez and donate more instruments to the conservatory in Riobamba.

Read More ↗

A new website and free membership for all 

In celebration of its 75th anniversary, ACMP is returning to its roots by dropping its membership dues. Read all about it, and about some of the new features of this new website (including helpful tips on how to renew your membership and tweak your personal profile.)

Read More ↗

Dutch Treat: ACMP to the Rescue!

Read More ↗

Kronos Quartet “50 for the Future” Online Masterclasses: Saturday, November 12, 2022 and Saturday, April 15, 2023 at 2pm Eastern on Zoom

Read More ↗

2022 Worldwide Play-In: U.S. Highlights

Read More ↗

2022 Susan McIntosh Lloyd Award: The Music Conservatory of Westchester

ACMP honors The Music Conservatory of Westchester with the 2022 Susan McIntosh Lloyd Award for Excellence and Diversity in Chamber Music Education

Read More ↗

 

All Articles By